The report “Google Buys Patents from IBM” is another captivating piece of industry news. The report highlights that a consortium formed by six major tech giants—Apple, Microsoft, Research In Motion (RIM), EMC, Ericsson, and Sony—secured the massive Nortel Networks patent portfolio with an unprecedented $4.5 billion winning bid.
Earlier on, I had noted that Google’s opening bid was far too modest; sure enough, the final auction tally came very close to my preliminary five-billion-dollar forecast.
Google announced this month that it has acquired a substantial portfolio of patents from IBM to bolster its intellectual property assets. In an emailed statement, Google remarked: “Like many tech companies, at times we’ll acquire patents that are relevant to our business.” The company has urged the US Congress and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to curb frivolous patent litigation while petitioning the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) to scrutinize disputed claims more rigorously. Kent Walker, Google’s General Counsel, noted in an interview earlier this week: “The tech industry faces a serious issue. Software patents have become a barrier to device innovation.” Google held approximately $39.1 billion in cash and short-term investments at the close of June. In April, Google submitted a stalking-horse bid of $900 million for Nortel’s 6,000+ patents, only to be outbid in late June by the Rockstar consortium (consisting of Apple, Microsoft, RIM, EMC, Ericsson, and Sony) at a staggering $4.5 billion. Walker termed the transaction “one of the largest patent sales in history.”
— Economic Daily News: “Google Buys IBM Patents”
Google’s loss in this bidding war was understandable. While Google held around $40 billion in liquid cash reserves, going head-to-head against a united coalition of deep-pocketed conglomerates proved virtually impossible. The long-term defensive and strategic potential of Nortel’s mobile patent portfolio was simply too critical for the consortium to let slip away.
Each member of this purchasing coalition represents an established titan in the mobile and networking space. Their coordinated move makes it abundantly clear that they collectively view Google’s Android ecosystem as their foremost threat, leading them to set aside their internal rivalries to form a united defensive front.
One fascinating question remains: how will these six companies divide and manage ownership across more than 6,000 acquired patents?
Attempting to appraise, dissect, and allocate individual patents across six entities would entail tremendous transactional friction, administrative complexity, and dispute. These corporations are far too savvy for that.
Instead of slicing up the portfolio, a far more effective strategy is for the newly incorporated joint venture to hold and manage the portfolio as a unified entity. When individual member companies require patent protection or countersuit leverage, they execute intercompany licensing agreements.
This structure achieves two critical objectives: first, it prevents any single member from monopolizing foundational standard-essential patents; second, licensing royalties flowing into the holding vehicle can be reinvested into acquiring future patent tranches, maximizing collective leverage while licensing the IP out to competitors. Before long, such an alliance could rival even IBM’s long-standing dominance in the IP arena (smiles).
Moreover, the real strategic kicker is that they can leverage this portfolio to demand hefty licensing fees directly from Google, turning the acquisition into an active revenue engine.
Google, however, reacted swiftly. By finalizing a quiet acquisition deal with IBM before issuing public announcements, they managed to plug immediate gaps in their IP armor (though IBM’s traditional corporate posture toward patent divestment has historically been nuanced, warranting further scrutiny into the exact terms).
Nevertheless, watching Google aggressively acquire patent portfolios on one hand while simultaneously lobbying against the validity of software patents on the other (the legitimacy of software patents has long been contentious, even though US courts initially established their precedent) leaves Google wide open to playful accusations of hypocrisy from competitors.
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account



Comments