Watchout once published an article or questionnaire quiz assessing whether users could achieve high scores on questions regarding the Three Principles of the People. The lower you scored, the higher the commendation Watchout awarded you, offering praise like “You have become a beneficiary of de-sinicization teaching materials.” Beneath the screenshots posted on Facebook, many netizens excitedly chimed in.
Looking at it from another angle, this is just like scoring a 10 on a math exam: in any classroom, there is always a group of slackers with zero marks who comfort each other for warmth—attempting to use foolish reasoning to deny the existence of intelligent people is truly something only fools (or scoundrels) would do.
Well, even if you do not want to be a citizen of the 🇹🇼 Republic of China (ROC) and wish to immigrate to the 🇺🇸 United States of America, you still have to pass a civics test. Even the United States, champion of freedom, enforces standardized testing criteria to weed out incompetence.
Do those who attempt to deny the Republic of China in hopes of founding a new island-nation of Taiwan genuinely expect a utopian fantasy where no one needs to understand the founding spirit of the nation, and everyone easily lands civil service jobs and enters the winner’s circle in life?
As the founding doctrine of the Republic of China (ROC), what was wrong with including the Three Principles of the People on examinations in an era when general education levels were far lower?
Or do netizens believe that when taking a civil service examination, the test questions should have been drawn from computer engineering and advanced engineering mathematics?
Why not ask why cavemen were not tested on physics and chemistry instead?
In past eras, everyone studied the same books and took the same exams; furthermore, no one landed a civil service position solely by passing this single subject.
If people failed to achieve what Watchout terms the “winner’s circle” (which was simply securing a civil service job—those aiming for massive wealth didn’t even bother taking it) despite having such equal opportunities, who is truly at fault? And why should those who studied diligently and passed the exams be condemned by internet commenters?
If Watchout had thoroughly investigated the flaws in the Three Principles of the People and authored an alternative monograph or new theoretical framework to challenge it, I would gladly welcome it.
However, taking a handful of past higher civil service examination questions, having a crowd of uninformed individuals answer them, and then rewarding those who failed by telling them their ignorance is wonderful—if that isn’t brainwashing, what is?
So don’t blame anyone for looking down on Watchout! The reason I criticize this website today is that they used a crude, hastily assembled quiz with the sole intent of smearing the Three Principles of the People. How much malice must dwell in one’s heart to do such a thing?
Ancient Chinese scholars remarked: “One takes the color of one’s company; what touches vermilion turns red, and what touches ink turns black.” Today, the biggest problem is that many individuals as dark as ink exploit internet discourse power to casually taint people’s minds. (More importantly, they often have excessive free time, which they spend manipulating internet narratives.)
In fact, it is not just this Watchout piece; too many similar articles deliberately adopt biased stances to frame their questions. For example, some people understand nothing of the Analects of Confucius, yet dismiss it entirely under the lazy label of “pedantic Confucianism”—they bear a striking resemblance to the Watchout crowd.
Ah, I forgot—they are almost always the exact same crowd of netizens.
No wonder people say rumors spread effortlessly, while speaking the truth until one is blue in the face falls on deaf ears.
In the Korean drama Argon, veteran journalist Shin Chul, when deciding whether to expose the reporting error of his friend and anchor Kim Baek-jin, remarked that people do not care about the factual truth at all; they only care about the outcome they desire.
When some individuals out of fear of China repeatedly repackage lavish anti-China sentiments and disseminate them, they care nothing for whether their methods are right, nor whether their arguments align with logic or historical context. Their sole aim is to brainwash their audience into accepting the ideas they wish to propagate.
The actions of these individuals bear an uncanny resemblance to the authoritarianism and figures they claim to despise.
Whatever Happened to Critical Thinking?
The phrase “critical thinking” has probably become one of the top three lies in recent years.
First, they wave the banner of critical thinking in your face, and then relentlessly indoctrinate you with the information they want you to blindly follow. If someone raises an opposing view, they immediately mobilize pitchforks and torches, accusing you of lacking critical thinking skills!
Critical thinking, my foot.
Well, I suppose I should thank Watchout’s quiz for inspiring me to formulate a new quote—though how much of it they will actually comprehend is beyond me: “Feeling immensely free yet deeply fearful in contemplation.” (Text / Wu Ming)
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account




Comments